British Classic Reimagined: Rhubarb & Custard vs Lemon Sherbet – A Flavour Showdown

Quick answer

If you crave a creamy, tangy-sweet nostalgia hit, Rhubarb & Custard is your pick. If you prefer a zesty, citrus-forward kick that wakes up your taste buds, Lemon Sherbet delivers. Both are plant-powered, no-nasties vegan sweets from the British Classic Reimagined range, so your choice comes down to flavour personality.

British sweets have a way of taking you straight back to childhood, and the British Classic Reimagined range from Candy Kittens turns those memories into gourmet, plant-powered treats. Two standouts—Rhubarb & Custard and Lemon Sherbet—offer completely different flavour experiences, and we're here to help you decide which one deserves a spot in your sweet drawer.

Both are made with no nasties, are vegan-friendly, and come in the same exclusive range for M&S. But when it comes to taste, texture, and the kind of craving they satisfy, they're worlds apart. Let's break down the trade-offs so you can choose with confidence.

Flavour profile: creamy nostalgia vs zesty brightness

Rhubarb & Custard is the classic combo of tart rhubarb and smooth, sweet custard. It's a flavour that feels comforting and familiar, with a gentle tang that balances the sweetness. If you love desserts like crumble or custard tarts, this sweet will hit that creamy, nostalgic note.

Lemon Sherbet, on the other hand, is all about sharp, citrusy zing. It's the kind of flavour that makes your mouth pucker just a little before the sweetness kicks in. If you enjoy sour candies or refreshing lemon drops, this one brings a lively, sherbet-like fizz that's more invigorating than comforting.

• Think about whether you're in the mood for a comforting, dessert-like treat or a bright, tangy pick-me-up.

Texture and bite: what to expect

While both are gourmet gummies, the British Classic Reimagined range focuses on flavour-packed, plant-powered sweets. The Rhubarb & Custard offers a softer, more melt-in-your-mouth feel that matches its creamy custard inspiration. It's a gentle chew that lets the flavour linger.

Lemon Sherbet typically brings a firmer, more candy-like texture that snaps or crunches slightly before giving way to the chewy centre. That textural contrast adds to the sherbet experience, making it a more active, playful bite. If you like your sweets with a bit of resistance, Lemon Sherbet is the way to go.

How to choose: match the sweet to the moment

Your choice might depend on the occasion. Rhubarb & Custard is perfect for cosy evenings, movie nights, or when you want a comforting treat with a cup of tea. Its creamy, nostalgic flavour pairs well with relaxed, low-key moments.

Lemon Sherbet shines when you need an energy boost—think afternoon slumps, road trips, or as a palate cleanser after a meal. Its bright, zesty profile is more refreshing and can be a great pick-me-up. If you're sharing, consider the Mixed Box to get both flavours in one go.

The trade-offs at a glance

• Flavour intensity: Rhubarb & Custard is mellow and comforting; Lemon Sherbet is sharp and zesty. Choose based on whether you want a gentle hug or a citrus wake-up call. Pick Lemon Sherbet for bold, tangy flavour; Rhubarb & Custard for subtle sweetness.
• Texture preference: Rhubarb & Custard offers a softer, creamier chew; Lemon Sherbet brings a firmer, more candy-like bite with potential fizz. If you like a soft melt, go Rhubarb; if you want a lively crunch, go Lemon.
• Versatility: The Mixed Box gives you both flavours, so you can enjoy variety without committing to one bag. Choose the Mixed Box when you want options or are sharing with friends.

Product facts at a glance

• A British Classic Reimagined: Rhubarb & Custard: The classic combo of rhubarb and custard is back—and it's had a gourmet glow-up. Nostalgia never tasted so... You get the authentic, comforting flavour of the British classic, reimagined with gourmet, plant-powered ingredients—perfect for those who love creamy, tangy sweets.
• A British Classic Reimagined Mixed Box: Introducing the new and exclusive British Classic Reimagined range for M&S - where timeless British favourites meet gourmet imagination. Rhubarb & Custard (2x 140g bags) The Classic combo of Rhubarb and Custard is back, and it's had a gourmet glow-up. If you can't decide between Rhubarb & Custard and Lemon Sherbet, the Mixed Box lets you enjoy both—ideal for sharing or for when your craving changes day to day.

Which one fits you?

Best for

• Those who love creamy, dessert-inspired sweets with a nostalgic twist
• Anyone who enjoys a gentle, comforting flavour that pairs well with tea or coffee

Not for

• If you prefer sharp, citrusy, or sour candies, Lemon Sherbet (or the Mixed Box) might suit you better
• If you're looking for a bold, intense flavour punch, Rhubarb & Custard may feel too subtle

Whether you lean toward the comforting embrace of Rhubarb & Custard or the zesty spark of Lemon Sherbet, the British Classic Reimagined range brings a gourmet, plant-powered twist to beloved British flavours. If you can't decide, the Mixed Box lets you enjoy both—so you never have to choose wrong again.