Candy Kittens | Gourmet Vegan Sweets | No Nasties. All Good

Candy Kittens Sour Edit vs Smittens Sour Edit: Which Sour Gummy Is Better?

Candy Kittens Sour Edit vs Smittens Sour Edit: Which Sour Gummy Is Better?

By Candy Kittens | Gourmet Vegan Sweets | No Nasties. All Good | Published: 2026-08-28

Category: Comparisons

Compare Candy Kittens Sour Edit and Smittens Sour Edit for flavor, texture, and value. Find out which sour vegan gummy suits your taste.

Sour sweets have a devoted fan base, and when you're vegan, finding the perfect tangy treat can feel like a treasure hunt. Two standout options from Candy Kittens are the Sour Edit and Smittens Sour Edit. Both promise mouth-puckering flavor without any nasties, but they deliver different experiences. In this comparison, we'll break down their flavor profiles, textures, and overall value to help you decide which sour gummy deserves a spot in your sweet drawer.

Smittens Sour Edit
Smittens Sour Edit

Whether you're a sour purist or new to the world of vegan gummies, understanding what sets these two apart can make all the difference. We'll look at what each has to offer, from the intensity of the sour coating to the chewiness of the gummy itself. By the end, you'll know exactly which one to reach for when that sour craving hits.

Flavor Showdown: Tangy vs Fruity

The Sour Edit from Candy Kittens is all about bold, tangy flavors that hit you right away. Think zingy citrus and sharp berry notes that make your taste buds sit up and pay attention. It's a classic sour experience, with a punchy sour sugar coating that gives way to a sweet, fruity center. If you like your sweets to make you pucker, this is the one.

Smittens Sour Edit, on the other hand, takes a slightly softer approach. The sourness is there, but it's more of a gentle tingle than a full-on assault. The flavors lean towards juicy, ripe fruits, with a sweetness that balances the tang. It's a great choice if you want a sour treat that's a bit more approachable, especially if you're sharing with friends who might not be sour enthusiasts.

  • Candy Kittens Sour Edit: intense, lip-smacking sourness with bold fruit flavors.
  • Smittens Sour Edit: milder sour kick with a sweeter, juicier profile.

Texture and Chew: Soft vs Firm

Texture plays a huge role in how much you enjoy a gummy. The Candy Kittens Sour Edit has a firmer chew, giving you a satisfying bite that lasts. The sour coating is gritty and generous, adding an extra layer of texture that contrasts nicely with the chewy interior. It's the kind of sweet you can savor slowly.

Smittens Sour Edit is noticeably softer and more pillowy. The gummies are easier to bite into, making them almost melt-in-your-mouth. The sour coating is lighter, so the texture feels smoother overall. If you prefer a gentler chew, Smittens might be your pick. Both are vegan and made with no nasties, so you can enjoy them without compromise.

  • Candy Kittens Sour Edit: firm chew, generous sour coating.
  • Smittens Sour Edit: soft, pillowy texture with a lighter sour dusting.

Value and Variety: Which Offers More?

When it comes to value, both options come in various sizes to fit different needs. The Candy Kittens Sour Edit is available in a range of packs, including the popular Sour Watermelon Mega Bag, which is perfect for sharing or stocking up. Smittens also offers a Taster Box, ideal for trying a few flavors before committing to a larger bag.

Consider how you plan to enjoy them. If you're hosting a party or want a big stash for movie nights, the mega bag from Candy Kittens gives you plenty. If you're curious about Smittens and want to sample, the Taster Box is a smart start. Both provide good value for the quality, so it really comes down to your flavor and texture preferences.

  • Candy Kittens Sour Edit: available in Sour Watermelon Mega Bag for sharing.
  • Smittens Sour Edit: Taster Box lets you try before you buy big.

So, which sour gummy comes out on top? It depends on what you're after. If you crave an intense, tangy kick with a firm chew, Candy Kittens Sour Edit is your winner. If you prefer a softer, sweeter sour experience that's easy to pop, Smittens Sour Edit takes the crown. Either way, you're getting a delicious vegan treat made with no nasties. Why not try both and decide for yourself?

Shop Related Products

"Candy" Cap

"Candy" Cap

$10.00 $20.00

Shop Now
Eton Mess 140g x 10

Eton Mess 140g x 10

$13.75 $27.50

Shop Now
Smittens Blueberry Edit

Smittens Blueberry Edit

$5.25 $10.50

Shop Now
A British Classic Reimagined: Lemon Sherbet

A British Classic Reimagined: Lemon Sherbet

$7.50 $15.00

Shop Now